The tables were turned on the Watch What Happens Live host last night when Real Housewife of Beverly Hills Lisa Vanderpump got her chance to put Andy in the hot seat and ask him anything. After covering some RHOBH business, Andy interjects to make sure Lisa knows she can ask him “anything [she] want[s].” With a devilish glean in her eye that seems to say, “challenge accepted,” she quickly fires back “When was the last time you had sex…with a woman?” 

“Never. Never full monty. I’m a gold star gay,” Andy retorts. Surprised by this revelation, Vanderpump then asks, “How do you know you don’t like it?” “Well, because I like dudes so much more.” Andy didn’t fully shut the door on the possibility of carnal relations with a lady, however: “I thought maybe it would be fun if I were in a throuple with a man and a woman.” Plot twist. 

Watch Lisa get up close and personal with Andy and discuss which one of the castmembers of Vanderpump Rules they think has done it with a dude, AFTER THE JUMP…