On Friday’s The Grace Helbig Show, former NSYNC member Lance Bass and newly minted late night host James Corden faced off in an musical ad-lib competition to see who could best recreate the late 90s/early 00s boy band fever.

Song titles, chosen by Helbig via Twitter, included “Popcorn on the Futon,” “Two Steps Into My Heart,” “Strawberry Cream Cheese,” “OMGGG,” “Retweet My Heart Bae,” and “Why Didn’t You Reply to My Text 3 Years Ago.”

Watch Corden and Bass create a musical masterpiece, AFTER THE JUMP…